Balvenie Caribbean Cask 14y

Milk and Toast and Honey

Reviewed by victor

A staple in my cabinet, albeit slightly forgotten in favor of whatever exciting sample or bottle that happens to catch my eye - and so the cabinet grows fuller. A review is overdue!

1.0 (Deep copper) - with artificial coloring


Subtle, quiet. Almost airy, which would be the opposite of full-bodied, I guess.


Quite thin - not much to chew on. But there is a plethora of tasty sweets here! Candied apples, toffee, tea with milk and honey.


Absolutely delicious caramel and a big load of vanilla. Lots of honey and milk chocolate. Medium length with a slightly peppery tail. Tiny bit of fruitiness as well.

Overall not very challenging or complex, but the sweet profile is nice anyway. I think this is clearly more interesting than the 12-year old DoubleWood. Easy sipper, good value, a small but important step up from the typical entry level Scotch. Oh, and if you're looking for actual rum flavors, I think you need to look elsewhere.


80 / 100
0-50 Subpar 51-60 Drinkable 61-70 Decent 71-80 Good 81-90 Great 91-100 Fantastic

Loading related reviews...